When it comes to preparing for a college music audition, it’s not enough to sound “good.” Judges want to hear the right level of difficulty — and that’s where music grades come in.
Unlike school grades (A to F), music uses a different system to measure how challenging a piece is to perform. Compositions are ranked from Grade I (very easy) to Grade VI (professional level). Understanding this scale is essential to choosing the right repertoire for auditions.
Who Sets the Music Grades?
Across the U.S., each state has its own Music Educators Association with divisions for Band, Orchestra, Choral, College, and General Music. Every summer, a Music Grading Committee meets to review new pieces and assign grades based on how hard they are to perform.
But here’s the catch: there’s no national grading system. Each state builds its own list, meaning the same piece can have different grades in different states!
Is There a Standard Everyone Follows?
Not officially — but some states have earned a reputation for being the gold standard.
Texas, New York, Florida, Virginia, Georgia, Indiana, and California are among the most respected. In fact, when colleges don’t specify a state system, they often expect you to use Texas’s rankings — even though Texas ranks the hardest pieces as Grade I and the easiest as Grade VI, the opposite of most states.
And if you’re looking for a trusted, nationwide reference? The Accoladi Repertoire Directory at Accoladi.com is one of the few resources that compares and curates music grades across states — the closest thing to a national standard available.
How Music Grades Line Up
Here's a quick guide:
Basic Music Grade Divisions
| School Grade |
Music Difficulty |
Common Grade |
Texas Grade |
| 6th Grade | Very Easy | Grade I | Grade VI |
| 7th Grade | Easy | Grade II | Grade V |
| 8th Grade | Moderately Easy | Grade III | Grade IV |
| 9th Grade | General Standard | Grade IV | Grade III |
| 10th Grade | Moderately Difficult | Grade V | Grade II |
| 11th–12th Grade | Difficult | Grade VI | Grade I |
Note: Florida’s list even goes up to Grade VII!
Why It Matters for Your Audition
Most colleges want audition pieces at Grade V or Grade VI level of difficulty. Some schools will tell you which state list they use. If not, assume Texas’s ranking— it’s often the unofficial standard.
Example:
Haydn’s Concerto in D for Solo Flute gets different grades depending on where you look:
• Maryland: Grade IV
• New York: Grade V
• Virginia: Grade VI
• Texas: Grade I (most difficult!)
Watch for Publisher Differences
One more twist: the same piece can have different grades depending on the publisher.
For instance:
• Air and Scherzo by Fox — published by Belwin Mills — is a Grade IV in Virginia.
• The same piece — published by Presser — is a Grade V also in Virginia.
Tip: Always check the publisher’s name when selecting your piece for auditions!
Final Note: Why It All Matters
Your audition isn’t just about playing a piece well — it’s about playing the right piece at the right level. Choosing wisely shows judges you’re not only talented but also prepared, disciplined, and serious about your craft.
When you know how to navigate the grading system — and use tools like the Accoladi Repertoire Directory — you give yourself a real edge.
The right piece can open the right doors. Master the grades, and let your music be the key that unlocks your future.